Powered By Blogger
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts

Sunday, August 14, 2016

While You Were Sleeping (College Essay on the Unconscious in Gothic Literature)

Picture Came from HERE
Stories are often, for the reader, a dream come to life. Stories offer us an escape from our reality and a chance to vicariously experience a different life from our own. However, not all stories are warm and fuzzy and not all dreams are sweet. There are times when a person is experiencing stress or oppression in their life that the repressed memories begin to find their way to the surface of their mind. Repressed thoughts and memories may manifest themselves into nightmares that are overwhelming and they make the escape from reality seem more like an impenetrable prison. While it may still be an escape from our own daily life’s reality, we instead find ourselves overcome by anxiety as we are having to face down and survive our manifested fears and repressed emotions. “In Freud's psychoanalytic theory of personality, the unconscious mind is a reservoir of feelings, thoughts, urges, and memories that [are] outside of our conscious awareness. Most of the contents of the unconscious are unacceptable or unpleasant, such as feelings of pain, anxiety, or conflict…Freud believed that many of our feelings, desires, and emotions are repressed or held out of awareness. Why? Because, he suggested, they were simply too threatening. Freud believed that sometimes these hidden desires and wishes make themselves known through dreams…” (verywell.com)
A person is haunted by a figure of repression that lurks in the depths of their very own psyche. Dracula, the main character of Bram Stoker’s novel (written in 1897) is the author’s monster, which is a repressed figure of unconscious fear. This monster, Count Dracula, “would translate culturally, historically and socially to repressed Victorian society. A group of people that outwardly felt civilised and at the peak of technological / industrial revolution. But inwardly still struggled with only comparatively nascent understanding of religion, superstition, science, psychology and the mind.” (Webb) The Victorian Era in British history (1837 to 1901) which overlapped the European Industrial Revolution (1760-1840), was a period of peace, prosperity, and refinement, with an outwardly social focus on morality, language, and behavior. The advancements in education, technology, and industry during this era of peace brought great wealth to several people while also rendering some folks useless when a machine replaced them in the work field. Despite the technology and machines invented for industrial improvements, humans are still subject to the effects of nature, which can render one helpless. Irish born author Bram Stoker watched as his homeland was struck with famine. Stoker saw his society struggle dwindle away despite the technology, the earth remained barren. They were helpless. These feelings of helplessness cause an internal struggle in the human psyche, we struggle to find meaning in life, as well as our reason for existing in this world. When the answers are not found in the natural realm, we search for the supernatural. Stoker chose to put pen to paper to create a story from the natural and supernatural world that he was witnessing first hand.
Bram Stoker’s novel, Dracula, is structured as a series of letters, journals, and personal diaries of the characters which represent this civilized society. Jonathan Harker, a London solicitor, travels outside of the modern city, and into a foreign country, where he meets the mysterious Count. Following Jonathan’s journal emphasizes the long stretches of time that he is alone on the journey and inside the castle. Between his diary entries, he wants to ignore what he thinks that he has seen and tries to doubt instead of confront. However, his unconscious is very aware of the fact that Dracula did not have a reflection in his shaving mirror, though he consciously denies this. There are several entries where Jonathan mentions “queer dreams” (12), “bad dreams” (40), repetitive dreams (21), and a desire to not dream (40). Jonathan chooses to continually repress these images and events into his unconscious instead of confronting what he has witnessed, which would go against the social moral norm of his Victorian beliefs.
            During Jonathan’s time that he is trapped inside the castle, he reports in his entries of other moments of unconsciousness which creep to the surface of awareness. “Feeling as though my own brain were unhinged or as if the shock had come which must end in its undoing, I turn to my diary for repose. The habit of entering accurately must help to soothe me.” (43) As Jonathan begins to let down his social etiquette, “The Count’s warning came into my mind, but I took a pleasure in disobeying it” (43), he also lets escape of his libido in pages 43 through 45 with the events of the three female vampires which he simultaneously desires and repulses. Jonathan never fully gives in to his desires, however, and manages to escape the castle and return to London.
            Meanwhile, back in London, Lucy is being overpowered by a mysterious oppression. She believes that her declining ailment is because of her somnambulism, or sleep-walking. She is also “so sweet and sensitive that she feels influences more acutely than other people do.”(89) Lucy is a perfect subject to aid Dracula in his quest for power, strength, and immortality. He needs her blood (her livelihood) in order to gain strength, to build a new estate in London with new followers, which will assure that his livelihood as a vampire will continue forever. The events that plague Lucy happen while she is asleep, in a trance-like state bringing harm to herself unconsciously. Lucy is not the only somnambulist that we encounter in Gothic fiction and film, we also know of a patient of Dr. Caligari in the film The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. This patient, Cesare, while in asleep in a trance-like state, unconsciously brings harm to others (i.e. murder).
Dr. Caligari and Dracula are using their power over the somnambulists in order to gain even more power/control in society; Dracula by gaining physical strength, and Caligari by gaining a better understanding. However, they both seem to wish for anonymity in this quest for power. Dracula wishes to blend into the crowd, and so he comes to Lucy as other creatures, or lures her out into the dark night where he can remain unseen. Dr. Caligari, we find out is the asylum director, Dr.Olsen, who has used the disguise of Dr. Caligari. These two men, the director and the doctor, are revealed to be two in one. “…Uncanny is unheimlich in German, or "unhomely", and Freud claims it is the home that we refuse to acknowledge and from which we are estranged which causes the double among other eerie manifestations.” (Kolokoz.Wordpress.com) “The eeriness of two selves where there should only be one is, Freud argued, an irruption of disquiet caused by our separation from our origin in our mother's womb...” (Kolokoz.Wordpress.com) The idea that being separated from the mother creates two selves within one person sparked an idea in filmmaker Alfred Hitchcock, who was a fan of psychology and had created several films exploring the ideas of psychology and fear.
One of Hitchcock’s most famous films is Psycho, in which the main character Norman Bates, a young man who lives alone, is not really alone. In fact, half of his mind belongs to his physically deceased Mother. Not knowing how to cope with the horror of her death, “[Norman] began to think and speak for her, give her half his life, so to speak...He was never all Norman, but he was often only Mother…After the murder, Norman returned as if from a deep sleep…When the mind houses two personalities, there is always a conflict, a battle, and in Norman’s case, the battle is over and the dominant personality has won.” (Dr. Fred Richman, Psycho) Norman returning as if from a deep sleep is a familiar notion, many of the Gothic stories use somnambulism as I had previously stated. Author Stephen King uses this notion as well in his novel, The Shining, in which a young boy named Danny is a clairvoyant that receives his visions while unconscious. Danny describes this as waking in "…darkness and a few minutes later he [comes] back to real things with a few vague fragments of memory, like a jumbled dream." (p.29)  Generally, in the trope of somnambulism, the characters wake up to find the reality of the terrible things that they had done while they were unconscious. However, in Danny's case, the unconsciousness is itself the horror for him. He is receiving visions of words that he is too young to understand or visions of frightful events from the future that will be committed by another person. Danny sees in his unconscious what the others do not see in theirs, yet he is still just as helpless to the events. To feel as if you are without help, or without control, is frightening.  These feelings of helplessness cause an internal struggle in the human psyche, we struggle to find meaning in life, as well as our reason for existing in this world. When the answers are not found in the natural realm, we search for the supernatural.
Gothic Fiction and Film is infused with elements of horror, death, psychology, and overall fear. While stories in general may be an escape from our own reality, we can find ourselves overwhelmed by anxiety as we come face to face with these manifested fears and repressed emotions of our unconscious mind. “The minds that have us believing that we are helpless are the same minds that can help us discover our own strength and ability. A great deal of that learning has to do with taking action, even if we don’t think we can, even if we don’t FEEL like it.” (Fearmastery Blog) Perhaps that is the appeal of these gothic stories, that we can escape our daily lives and live vicariously through another person who is also facing our manifested fear and together with them, we take action against the monster and we survive.

Citations:
Stoker, Bram. Dracula. Pyramid Books. 1965. New York City. Print
Webb, Carol – DM conversation on Twitter. https://carolslearningcurve.com/
Kracauer, Siegfried. From Cabinet to Hitler: The Cabinet of Caligari. 2004. Oxford University Press. New York City. Print.






Deceit or No Deceit- That is the Question


 ”Sigh no more, ladies, sigh no more,
 Men were deceivers ever,
 One foot in sea and one on shore,
 To one thing constant never.” (II.iii.4)



The art of deception plays a significant role in stories and works of literature throughout history. Deception is especially evident in William Shakespeare’s plays Othello and Much Ado About Nothing. The former play is a tragedy while the latter is considered a comedy. Do not be deceived by the title of comedy though, both of these plays are extravagantly filled with trickery, slander, and lies.  The idea that people, events, and things in our world are often not what they seem is at the very heart of many of Shakespeare’s plays, “[t]hus the hyperbole of tragedy stands at the opposite end of a tonal scale from the hyperbole of comedy” (Mack, 156)
Every good story has a protagonist and an antagonist- a hero and a villain. These oppositional characters are often referred to as foil characters because they reflect the extremes of the other. In Othello, the hero is the man for which the play is named… Othello. While his “foil” character is Iago. Iago manipulates the mind of Othello by taking advantage of his insecurities. Othello is a great leader, though he is not as educated or well-bred as the beautiful Desdemona, his wife. Because Iago understands people and the psychology of the mind, he uses this knowledge to his advantage. Throughout the play, Iago plants seeds in Othello’s mind, convincing him slowly that the desirable Desdemona has been unfaithful to him, with his lieutenant Cassio. Similarly, in Much Ado About Nothing, the antagonist Don John manages to convince Claudio that the lovely and beautiful Hero is not as innocent or virtuous as he believes her to be. These lies of infidelity are slanderous at best. It seems as though Iago and Don John are motivated by their envy to bring destruction to Othello and Claudio.  
This heavy theme of deception takes a tragic turn in Othello, which begins in the city of Venice, where there is control and order.  It is taken shortly thereafter to Cyprus, where there is a war being fought, less people to surround Othello, and less stability in the structure of his council which eventually leads to Othello’s downfall and the death of four people within two marriages. In contrast, the play Much Ado About Nothing is set in Messina, Sicily, after the success of a war. This story takes place in a home with the stable council of family and patriarchal dominance where the conflict is resolved with non-violence in a happy outcome of four people coming together into two marriages.
In literature, a comedy is not necessarily a humorous tale, but rather a tale with a happy ending. Much Ado About Nothing has both a happy ending and humor. The characters of Beatrice and Benedick are considered secondary characters, however the “merry war” that has been an ongoing conflict between them is light hearted and witty.  They too, fall victim to deception in this tale, however, when their companions intentionally hold conversations knowing that they each could overhear, stating that one was in love with the other. These lies are not entirely untrue, for it seems that the continued witty banter between Beatrice and Benedick has proven itself facilitative in creating a mutual loving affection. There is also humor in the night watchmen, Dogberry and his companions, who capture Don John’s men (Boracio and Conrad) and shed light to the deception of Claudio and slander of Hero by telling her father Leonato of the ruse.  Leonato, Hero, and the family decide to carry out the deception that they fashioned at the disastrous first wedding… that Hero is dead, having died at the shock of offence to her character.  Leonato and his brother do tell Claudio what the night watchmen discovered and then instruct Claudio to mourn Hero’s death, and that if he is a good and noble man, he will marry her cousin in her stead. Claudio agrees. At the gathering of the second wedding, all of the deceit is brought to light, Don John caught, and two marriages take place: Claudio to Hero and Benedick to Beatrice.
“Comic overstatement aims at being preposterous … tragic overstatement, on the other hand, aspires to be believed.” (Mack, 156)  Othello ends tragically with the death and destruction of the great leader who believed in and fell victim to the embroidered web of lies. In Contrast, Much Ado About Nothing ends laughably and over-joyously with the enlightenment of truth, the birth of new relationships, and the resolution and apprehension of the deceiver Don John. These stark and drastic differences make it hard to imagine that both tales are centered on the idea that people, events, and things in our world are often not what they seem… that at the very heart of these two contrary love stories we find deception. 
“Deceiving others. That is what the world calls a romance.” ― Oscar Wilde


Citation Page
Shakespeare, William. Much Ado About Nothing. Act 2. Scene 3. Page 4
Mack, Maynard. “The Jacobean Shakespeare.” The Tragedy of Othello The Moor of Venice with New and Updated Critical Essays and a Revised Biography. Ed. Alvin Kernan. New York: Signet Classics, 1998. 156. Print.